Buying out minority shareholders in Japanese M&A and business succession
Hello, I'm Noriaki Asato, Representative Attorney at Legal Agent.
Suppose a buyer says it wants to acquire all the shares in a company. The founder holds 85% of the voting rights and a former director holds the remaining 15%. Even if the founder sells every share, the buyer acquires only 85% of the votes. That falls short of the 90% threshold for acquiring the remaining shares as a special controlling shareholder. In a family business succession, too, the votes the successor can actually assemble determine which procedures are available.
Start by discussing the number of shares, the price and the payment date with shareholders you can reach. For shares subject to transfer restrictions, check how the company must approve the transfer. If voluntary agreements will leave the buyer short of its target, the alternatives depend on how each shareholder acquired the shares and who holds the votes.
A company's demand that heirs sell their shares
Even shares subject to transfer restrictions pass to the heirs on the shareholder's death. Under Article 174 of the Companies Act, a company may provide in its articles of incorporation that it can require a person who acquires restricted shares by inheritance or other general succession to sell them to the company. The company buys the shares. An acquisition by the successor personally involves a different payer and leaves a different ownership structure.
For each demand, a special resolution of the shareholders must identify the seller and the number of shares. The targeted heir or other successor cannot vote on the resolution unless none of the other shareholders can vote (Articles 175 and 309(2)(iii)). The company loses its right to make the demand one year after learning of the general succession (Article 176(1)).
The company and the heir negotiate the price. Either may ask the court to determine it within 20 days of the demand. If neither reaches agreement nor files a petition within that period, the demand lapses (Article 177). Check the amount available for distribution that the company can use for the purchase (Article 461). When adding the provision to the articles, consider how it might affect the founder's own successor if that person inherits the founder's shares.
A sale demand by a special controlling shareholder with at least 90% of the votes
Article 179 generally requires at least 90% of all shareholder voting rights. A higher threshold in the articles of incorporation applies. Count the voting rights of the person making the demand and its qualifying wholly owned entities. Relatives' votes cannot be added merely because the relatives support the same acquisition.
As a rule, the special controlling shareholder may require all other shareholders to sell all their shares. It may exclude its qualifying wholly owned entities and may demand the sale of share options alongside the shares. The purchaser sets out the consideration, acquisition date and other terms and obtains the target company's approval. A company with a board of directors must have its board decide whether to approve the demand. No shareholders' meeting is required. After approval, the target must generally notify the selling shareholders and other affected holders at least 20 days before the acquisition date (Articles 179-2 to 179-4).
A shareholder who disputes the price may petition the court from 20 days before the acquisition date through the day before acquisition. Statutory interest accrues on the court-determined price after the acquisition date. The purchaser may pay an amount it considers fair before the court rules (Article 179-8). A shareholder at risk of disadvantage on a ground specified in Article 179-7, such as a violation of law or grossly unfair consideration, may also seek an injunction against the acquisition.
Fractional shares and shareholder rights in a share consolidation
In the opening example, assume there are only 100 ordinary shares and each carries one vote. In a 20-for-1 consolidation, the holder of 85 shares would have four whole shares and a fraction equivalent to 0.25 of a share. The holder of 15 shares would have a fraction equivalent to 0.75 of a share and no whole share. As a rule, the company auctions the number of shares corresponding to the combined fractions and distributes the proceeds in proportion to those fractions. For shares without a market price, it may obtain court approval for a sale by another method (Articles 234(2) and 235).
The shareholders adopt a special resolution setting the ratio, effective date, total authorized shares on that date and other required terms. The directors must explain why the consolidation is necessary (Article 180(2) and (4)). As a rule, holders of a majority of the eligible voting rights must attend, and at least two-thirds of the votes represented must be cast in favor. Check the articles for an adjusted quorum or a higher approval threshold and determine whether a separate class meeting is required (Article 309(2)(iv), among other provisions).
A shareholder entitled to vote must notify the company of its opposition before the meeting and vote against the consolidation to qualify as a dissenting shareholder. A shareholder who cannot exercise voting rights at the meeting also qualifies. Either may demand that the company buy at a fair price all the shares that would become a fractional interest. The demand must be made from 20 days before the effective date through the preceding day (Article 182-4). If the parties do not agree on a price within 30 days of the effective date, either may petition the court during the following 30 days. Statutory interest on the price fixed by the court runs after the 60-day period from the effective date expires (Article 182-5).
Working back from negotiations and the closing date
If the buyer requires full ownership, calculate the voting rights it would obtain with and without each shareholder's agreement when negotiating the letter of intent. For an inheritance, check the articles and when the company learned of the succession. For a controlling shareholder's demand, schedule the acquisition date and notice deadline. For a consolidation, allow time for the shareholders' meeting and the disposal of fractional interests. The choice also determines who must fund the purchase and how much to set aside.
Reconcile the shareholder register with past transfer records. If a shareholders' agreement covering founder shares contains joint-sale provisions or transfer restrictions, check when they apply. Prepare the valuation materials supporting the offer where price negotiations may be difficult. Recording how the price and the consolidation ratio were considered when the company grants approval or the shareholders vote will help explain those decisions to shareholders or a court.